Weapons-Mystical Artifacts
| # | A | B | C | D |
| .45 caliber Wrought iron rounds | Acacia | Backpacks | Cat's Eyes | Dead Man's Blood |
| African Dream Root | Battleaxe | Ceremonial Dagger | Dean's Amulet | |
| Aliases | Bowhunting | Charm Amulet | Dean's Bowie Knife | |
| Angel Sword | Collapsible Straight Batons | Dean's Journal | ||
| Angelic Weapon | The Colt | Death's Scythe | ||
| Angelica Root | Crossbow | Devil's Shoestring | ||
| Ark of the Covenant | Crowley's Gun | Dreamcatcher | ||
| Crucifix/Cross | Duffel bags | |||
| Curse Box | ||||
| F | G | H | I | J |
| The First Blade | Gabriel's Horn of Truth | Hand of Glory | Iron | John's Journal |
| Flare Guns | Goofer Dust | Hellhound Glasses | ||
| Flasks | Gris-gris bag | Hex Bag | ||
| Fulgurite | Holy Oil | |||
| Holy Water | ||||
| K | L | M | N | O |
| Key to Oz | Laptop | Machete | Newspaper clipping-Rolling Stones Concert | Oil of Abramelin |
| Key to the Bunker | Lockpick Kit | Magical Coin | ||
| Knuckledusters/Brass Knuckles | Lot's Salt | Mandaic Amulet | ||
| Mark of Cain | ||||
| Meadowsweet | ||||
| Mjolnir | ||||
| P | R | S | T | V |
| Palo Santo | Rabbit's Foot | Salt | Tablets | Vamptonite |
| Pistols | Rifle | Sam's Journal | Tarot Cards | Van Van Oil |
| Pocket Knife (Dean) | Rock Salt Cartridges | Sam's Knife | Tasers | |
| Pocket Knife (Sam) | Rope | Shotguns | Tiamat Talisman | |
| Poppets | Rosary | Shuriken (Star Knife) | Torch/Flashlight | |
| Purgatory Weapons | Ruby's Knife | Silver | ||
| Silver Bullet | ||||
| Silver-tipped Bows and Arrows | ||||
| Spearhead | ||||
| Spirit Board | ||||
| SpongeBob placemat | ||||
| Staff of Moses | ||||
| Subsonic rounds | ||||
| Suppressor | ||||
| Sword of Bruncvik | ||||
| W | ||||
| Weapons Box | ||||
| Wooden Mallet | ||||
| Wooden Stake |